Translate

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Post-election notes

The country is still covered with billboards, posters, signs hanging at the entrances to town. Along the drive leading into Santa Cruz del Quiché from Chichicastenango, trees along both sides are plastered with posters for the UCN. One wonders about the parties that clearly had enough money to pay someone to put all of those signs up, but didn't get more than one percent of the vote.

The news has been full of stories about the transition. As far as I can see (and I haven't yet looked closely) the appointees of the new government are mostly men and a lot of them are former military. I don't think this comes as much of a surprise.

Political cynicism and opportunism is rampant. The former president of the congress, José Roberto Alejos, along with seven other congresspeople, announced that they were leaving the party under whose banner they were elected (or re-elected), the Union Nacional de Esperanza (UNE), the party of the current president, and that they were going to be independent congresspeople. Even on the music radio station (I've become habituated to listening to the one station that plays mostly U.S. top-40 music; we are all allowed our little idiosyncrasies and this is one of mine), the DJs this morning were criticizing this maneuver. The basic thrust of the DJs' commentary was, If they were going to do this, they should have done it before the election. But instead they were waiting to see which way the wind was blowing and then they abandoned their party.  

People seem to take it for granted that the congress does nothing, and that people are elected to congress for purposes other than serving the people, mostly for personal gain.  

Meanwhile, Christmas decorations are going up. There are tall artificial trees erected in the center of Santa Cruz del Quiché's Parque Central, in front of the Cathedral, and at the Obelisco, in Guatemala City. They are covered with tinsel and metallic ornaments, and the major brewery, Gallo, is sponsoring some events to start the Christmas season. On the other hand, religious groups are putting up billboards saying that Christmas without Jesus is a travesty (I will get the exact wording the next time I pass the billboard on Calzada Roosevelt).

And those on the left, and in the Maya movement (which overlap to a degree) are trying to get their bearings and figure out strategies for surviving and negotiating the next four years. I don't think any of us are very sanguine about what the new government means for, say, the legalization of community radio, or women's rights. Most seem to think that there will be more concessions to transnational mining companies, more ravaging of the environment, more selling off the country's resources, and not much on the positive side. Both parties in the second round said that they would maintain the social programs instituted by the current government -- the "bolsa solidaria" (solidarity bag: a monthly food basket), and Mi Familia Progresa (my family progresses), a cash handout. Both programs have been criticized for just giving handouts and not providing any sustainable means to bring families out of poverty -- which is what they were ostensibly established for. Handing a woman 300 quetzales in cash will help take care of basic needs but it will not make her literate or otherwise give her skills that will allow her to earn a living (I won't say "get a job" since for women in rural areas with many children, and where there are no jobs in the first place, that's not a very reasonable proposition). The bolsa solidaria has been criticized because it consists of giving people staple food items rather than food coupons, which they could use at local stores, thus helping stimulate local economies, and also exercise some independence in choosing what to purchase.

But beyond that are the larger issues about pushing for policies and laws that do more to protect indigenous communities and also that fully comply with the peace accords. It's been 15 years (or it will be 15 years next month; December is the anniversary) and so much is still up in the air.

Monday, November 7, 2011

Tragedy, farce, a bit of both? Bad news in any case

I started this Sunday evening, November 6, when I was still in California:

The vote count is not yet final, but with over 90% of the ballots scrutinized, Otto Pérez Molina has over 54% of the votes for president, and Baldizón has about 44%. I am not surprised -- although there were some polls in the last week that showed Baldizón as the winner, others that showed Pérez Molina as the winner, enough so that it didn't seem a done deal. But it is deeply, deeply disappointing and disturbing nonetheless. I've started to look at the results in Quiché, municipality by municipality, and it seems that in a few of the communities where OPM was responsible for massacres, at least the PP did not get a majority, but as a friend pointed out, they still got around 40% in most places.  Here are some of the breakdowns:  Chiché (58%), Zacualpa (51.98%), Chajul (56.3%), San Antonio Ilotenango (63.46%), San Andres Sajcabaja (62.96%), Sacapulas (62.47%), Canilla (50.49%), Chicaman (51.36%), Ixcan .  (66.02%), Joyabaj (57.31%), Nebaj (55.51%). Chajul and Nebaj were sites of massacres for which Pérez Molina was directly responsible (as a commander), Ixcan is where a lot of ex-combatents were settled after the war. In my town of Chinique, the PP got over 60%.

The final vote count was 53.74% for Pérez Molina and 46.26% for Baldizón.  When I arrived today (we are back in the present tense now), I half expected to see orange banners flying in the streets and a lot of jubilant people. Life seemed much as normal -- well, as normal as I could tell from the little I see of Guatemala City, which is the road from the airport and then Calzado Roosevelt out of the city. Nothing much was happening, people were waiting at bus-stops, street vendors were carrying baskets on their heads, the women on the side of the highway north of Chimaltenango were fanning the flames to grill ears of corn. On the surface nothing seemed different, at least as much as could be seen through the window of a car. I would venture to say that most ordinary Guatemalans do not have very high expectations of politicians or of the political process and that people were probably just glad to get the elections over.

The general was on the radio several times giving interviews on different radio stations as I flipped through and nauseatingly enough thanked Radio Sonora, one of the major news stations, for their support.  Apparently he will be doing a victory tour, traveling around the country thanking people for voting for him. I am not looking forward to his forays into Quiché, but I suppose I will have to observe some of them.

So this still leaves a burning question about why a majority Maya population would vote in someone whose hands are drenched in the blood of their cousins, neighbors, parents, friends... It is true that the general received more votes from the areas with a higher concentration of non-Maya and wealthy people, but as my friend notes, even getting 45% in predominantly Maya communities in Quiché is not good -- that is, if one's interest is in seeing Maya communities have a forceful voice for themselves, and be able to push for the compliance with the Peace Accords and other national and international conventions that guarantee indigenous people's rights. We know that votes were purchased on a massive scale in the first round, and I would assume that the same was true this round.

We have a lot of work cut out for us in the next four years -- and I say "we" because I intend to stay involved with the Guatemalan left (such as it is) and see what I can do to be helpful so that 2015 might have a different outcome -- at least in some congressional races if not at the presidential level.

One of my friends wrote a long and somewhat painful reflection about why there was such as rejection of Winaq, the indigenous political party, which only became a political party in April of this year.  It is worth quoting at length:
I don't know why they are so repelled by Winaq
It took something away from them
It left them with something
But it only has 9 months of being a party
And they atack it as though it were the worst thing in the country.
Winaq is just one more party
The difference is that it has a Maya name and the majority of those who direct it are Mayas
And of course, since we are mayas, we are not good
But Adela Toerrebiarte [candidate for another party] is a ladina,
And it doesn't bother us that she has her party
And that she came in last place
Who criticizes her? No one...
or is the problem with Rigoberta?
The commentaries that I have heard about her outside of the country are very good and they
appreciate her a lot.
And so,
I, why can I not appreciate her.
Why can I not believe in her?
Why can I not be one of her followers?
Why can I not follow her to the ravine
And jump into it with her?
Because they make me feel that she is the worst thing...
Enough already with so much Malinchismo

*************
The word "malinchismo" needs a bit of a gloss. Malinche was the indigenous Mexican woman who was Cortes' lover and translator. She is often criticized by Mexican nationalists (mostly male) for betraying her people. She is often referred to very crudely as "la chingada" (the one who was fucked). In the last few decades, Latin American feminists have critiqued the gender politics of this characterization of Malinche-as-traitor. So when my friend refers to Malinchismo here, he is saying that there is a lot of machismo in the rejection of Rigoberta; she is a Maya woman who has "stepped out of her place".

Sunday, November 6, 2011

The second round, or la media vuelta

There is a beautiful Cuban song, "La media vuelta" (the half turn) that was set to a rumba rhythm some years back, I'm not sure by whom.  The persona of the song is man who is telling his beloved he wants her to go around the world and look for someone who is his equal, to kiss other lips ... but then, if she finds someone who loves her better than anyone, he will do a half turn and leave with the sun ("entonces yo daré la media vuelta, y me iré con el sol, cuando muera la tarde."). For some reason the refrain of that song and the image of the half-turn has been in my mind today as I have been sitting in the quiet, clean, modern comfort of a 1960s apartment building in San Diego, California (actually La Jolla), as I have been contemplating today's election in Guatemala, and wishing, vainly, that I could be there.

To what end, I don't exactly know. I cannot vote; there are no alternative parties that I would support in this round. But reading what my friends have been writing about their anguish, their mixed feelings, on this day, I guess I would want to be there just to be able to hug them, to sit and talk with them, to share a drink, to share  a laugh, a cry, a manifestation.  I don't know what I would do if I were there: scream, rage, cry, laugh, protest. The latter doesn't seem a very viable option; no one on the left is putting together any kind of alternative response. And so, I would probably sit in my home, or go out to one of the voting centers.

What I read in the paper was that they have sent 50 extra police to my little town, to try and prevent a reoccurrence of the mob that struck on September 11 (actually the early hours of the morning on September 12). And a total of 250 extra police or soldiers for the department of Quiché as a whole.  For the sake of everyone who is voting and the people working at the polls, I hope that the partisans of the major parties, who are the ones behind the violence, decide to allow the faulty and fractured democratic process, such as it is, to proceed without throwing up additional obstacles.  During the few days before my departure, there were news stories about meetings with the political parties asking them to keep their sympathizers in line, and also some ads from the Tribunal Supremo Electoral urging people to respect the results of the elections.

Another bit of electoral ephemera was a story on Guatemalan radio a few days ago, maybe the day I left, that in several municipalities where there had been violence around the September 11 election, the Tribunal Supremo Electoral  could not find anyone who was willing to help out with the vote count, because all the local residents were worried about retribution, and that these municipalities had had to appeal to the TSE to bring in people who were not residents of the municipality to work on the vote count.

I want to share some of the reflections of my beloved friends here, to give you a sense of how people are thinking. One friend, an activist with Winaq (the indigenous political party) late last night wrote that he was planning to cast a blank or null ballot. He just couldn't bring himself to vote for either party.

Another friend, who was in the armed resistance when he was young, and is also a supporter of Winaq,  wrote a series of updates on Facebook, and I'm going to translate:  "The polling place is very close, a block from my house; I wish that the elections were like something that is written on paper, like a story, like a document and that the crayon that I am going to use was an eraser to put an end to that which is written; but the reality is something else, I only dream that with the marker I can say to the one who committed genocide, that we continue being enemies and that with me, he will never sign  Peace Accords, because I don't forgive him for having killed my sisters and brothers, because I have dignity. So I will vote against [him]."  Later, he wrote, "I have passed the bad time, in the table [at the pollling place] they gave me another little piece of apper that says 'Proof of voting general elections 2011.' I asked them 'What good is this?' They said, 'For some transaction or procedure.' [the word 'trámite' is used to refer to official transactions, filling out paperwork, as in getting a license or taking money out of the bank]. I said to them, didn't it seem that this was ridiculous...how they try to fool us, and they fool us... now we have to wait 4 years more in order to see if an alternative appears...now there is none."

My friend Gustavo's wall post. The text reads, "Justice: one
more product what we can purchase."
His last comment (as of now) was, "It is clear, my friend, that in Latin America, 'the military has been a great problem,' that's how it's been, and the worst os that in Guatemalan, the civilian rules are thieves, assassins, sons of .... Here in order to find one that is honest, incorruptible, one has to go out an search with the light of the sun and lighting our way with a candle."

Another friend, Gustavo (actually the 19-year old son of the person cited above), wrote a series of short updates yesterday and today, "It would be suicide to vote for the genocide," "I am going to vote against Otto," "Guatemala Never Again." The latter was the title of the massive report published in 1998 detailing the genocide of the 1980s; the chief author of the report, Monsignor Juan Gerardi, was killed in his residence two days after the report's publication, so the title "Guatemala Never Again" has a double significance.  This morning, Gustavo wrote, "I put on the t-shirt that my father brought me from NIcaragua, ready to go to the polls for the second time and for the first time. My ideology is very clear, my ideals are very strong, my dreams very grand. This one is the great devil, my vote is against the other one. We cannot change the country with either of these two who have trampled on us. It is sad to have to wait four more years to see if by some miracle a real political option will appear. The truth for me is that, it would be suicide to support the one who participate in genocide. But we have to be realistic and know that we are at the brink of a sad election for president. More than sad, depressing. Here we are always ready and prepared to struggle."

I am both heartened and saddened to read these missives. I wanted to reach out and hug both father and son, two of my dear friends, and share directly in their emotions of the day. But I am a thousand or so miles to the north, in California, only in Guatemala in my mind. Tomorrow I will arrive in the morning; since most of my journey will be at night, I don't know how I will find out about the results as the count will be overnight. Hopefully we will have some results.

Another friend and I were chatting online today, and he told me that he thought that the Partido Patriota was very scared (which might mean that they act violently). When I told him about the threats against the election observers from the Maya youth organization in four municipalities, he replied, "That means that the PP must be scared." And when I added that they had sent 50 additional police to Chinique, he responded, "Then they really are scared."

Saturday, November 5, 2011

Elections, violence, democracy

This probably won't be the last blog I write about the elections, or about violence, political or otherwise. I have been out of Guatemala for 24 hours but it is never far from my mind, and I have mixed feelings about not being in the country for the second round of the presidential election tomorrow. On the one hand, while I am very clear that I do not want Otto Pérez Molina to be elected the next president, I don't strongly support his opponent, Manuel Baldizón, so it's not as though I have a horse in this race to which I am emotionally attached. I'd be interested to see what the mood is; my sense is that apart from a few party loyalists, no one is very excited about the elections and I am not sure how high the voter turnout will be. People to whom I speak seem resigned or indifferent, or a bit anxious about the results. But not eagerly looking forward to the day as a great civic festival, as the radio ads from the Tribunal Supremo Electoral are exhorting citizens to make of this day.  On the other hand, since there has been an unusually high level of electoral violence, and my town is having not only a repeat of the presidential election but the mayoral election as well, I think it might not be a bad idea to not be around, as there was a mob and a riot during the vote count on the first round.

I was just reading two articles in local papers that occasioned this reflection. One noted that this year's electoral violence is the highest on record: 43 fatalities, 39 people injured, and a few dozen other incidents. The other article reported that RENOJ, a Maya youth organization that is sending electoral observers to 120-odd municipalities, has reported that at least four of its staff have received threats and intimidations from the two political parties in contention -- and one of the places where threats had been received was Chinique.

Although there are some non-partisan organizations that are organizing transportation for people from rural areas, I do not know how high the turnout will be, which means that the vote that may decide the outcome is the urban vote. 

And then there was another article about discrimination in the electoral registration processes. Many Maya voters have been effectively disenfranchised because the voter registration system cannot seem to properly register their names, which often involve an apostrophe or two.  This seems like linguistic discrimiation. As Judith Maxwell, a linguistic anthropologist whom I've met and who was quoted in the article notes, it's not as though computer keyboards cannot produce the proper symbol. And when the linguists developed a standardized Maya alphabet, they specifically chose symbols that were standardly used on typewriters and computer keyboards.  To be sure, Maya are not the only people who have not been able to vote because there are errors in the spelling of their names or their birth dates. The Dean of Anthropology and History at the university where I was teaching received a personal identification document with a birth date of 1711, and had to hire a lawyer to get it changed (I'm not sure she's succeeded in time for this election).

So welcome to electoral democracy, Central American style.


Thursday, November 3, 2011

Community radio workshop on reproductive and sexual health, part 1

The community radio movement has been planning workshops for people in various radio stations.  A few months ago I came to a workshop held at Radio Doble Via in San Mateo, where we discussed human rights, the rights of indigenous people, and then recorded radio spots on those themes. The next workshop which was the weekend of October 29-30, was on reproductive and sexual health. This has been an issue that Ixmukané has been focusing on for a while, although I haven't been able to attend sessions -- some of the health promoters have been conducting workshops with young people.

So, it took some doing to make sure that someone from Ixmukané other than me attended the workshop. I happened to find out about it since I am in contact with people from the community radio movement more generally, and one of the key organizers, Anselmo, had told me about the workshop a few weeks back. I then contacted Rosendo, who was in charge of letting the radio stations know.

This needs a bit of backtracking. There are a few hundred radio stations in Guatemala that call themselves "community radio". Some of them are religious stations, broadcasting on behalf of a church or a denomination. There is a network of stations - not sure quite how many -- that are part of an institution called FGER (Guatemalan Federation of Radiophonic Schools: Federación Guatemalteca de Escuelas Radiofónicas). I think it's about a dozen. But this is a religious network of radios. What we define as the "movement of community radios" or the "real community radios" is a more limited number: maybe about 80 or 100.  Within that network, a group of about 20 radios have been identified as "pilot radios" -- radios that are receiving some special support and training through Cultural Survival and the Asociación Mujb'ab'l yol (which means "meeting of expressions" in Mam, one of the 22 Maya languages).  Our radio has been included in this group of 20 stations that are receiving these training sessions.

Because I have developed my own network of contacts with the people in the leadership of Mujb'ab'l yol, and the staff of Cultural Survival and thus the leadership of the "community radio movement", I thus sometimes have access to information, because I stay in touch with these folks fairly regularly. SoI found out that there was going to be a training session and said I wanted to attend but would pay my own way so that I didn't end up taking the space that had been reserved for our station: because of resources. The workshops include transportation, lodging and meals -- the training sessions are held in San Mateo, near Xela, and the radio stations that participate are located in other departments.  The city of San Marcos is about 40 minutes, and Momostenango, where one of the stations is located, is about an hour and a half away, but otherwise, people have to travel at least 3 hours to get to San Mateo, so it is a bit of a commitment, and since most people are volunteers at their stations and no one is wealthy, people can't really attend unless their costs are covered. I am always impressed and humbled by the effort that people make to attend these workshops. One of the men, whose name I forget but whom I like a lot, comes from Jalapa, which is at least 8 hours each way.  Nearly all use public transportation, which is crowded, smelly (diesel fumes) and uncomfortable. I took the bus one time, back at the end of June, when my car was in the shop, and it was not a pleasant ride, and our buses were not even that crowded.

Originally the workshop was to have been held the weekend of October 22 and 23rd, and I had made an elaborate plan to be able to attend the workshop and also visit Occupy Wall Street -- booking an evening flight on Sunday, figuring I could leave San Mateo late Sunday morning and make it to the airport for a 6 p.m. flight, so I wouldn't have to miss the workshop. But then after purchasing my ticket, the workshop was postponed for a week because of the weather and the condition of the highways. Although the worst of the rains had stopped and the major blockages on the highway were actually cleared by the time the workshop would have been held, the organizers decided some days in advance to postpone.  I was mildly annoyed - yes, very petty of me, I know. I would have undoubtedly made my trip to New York at least a day longer (i.e. I would have left earlier, like over the weekend) but it was too late to change the ticket without incurring a lot of additional costs.

It is not always easy to make things happen at Ixmukané. The organization has a lot of projects under way at once, and the projects all seem to involve a lot of bureaucratic paperwork. So getting the attention of the leadership of the organization for anything that is not a hot-button issue is difficult. And sometimes at the radio station we feel as though we are forgotten. Everyone likes the fact that we exist but we don't receive a lot of attention unless there is a crisis or unless we are needed for something (like to do a live transmission of some activity that the organization has sponsored).

I wanted to be sure that someone from Radio Ixmukané attended the workshop because the person who attended the June workshop, Lucero, is no longer working at the radio (although she is still working for Ixmukané, but she moved to a different project).  I have my own agenda here: in order for our radio station to develop, the people involved in it need to feel that they are part of something larger, a real movement. My own experience of attending the June workshop and the national encounter of community radios in Guaemala in June was very inspiring, and while my compañeros might not have exactly the same reaction, I think that they will get a greater sense of the politics of community radio. That it is a movement. That it is connected with the right of indigenous peoples to have the means of self-expression. Too often, it seems to me, the folks at Radio Ixmukané have just viewed it as a job. But the other stations, where no one (or almost no one) receives a salary, people make radio because they need to make radio.  That consciousnes and that urgency have seemed to be lacking. And I think we will make better radio at Radio Ixmukané if people have a sense of the bigger picture, and understand why community radio is so urgently important.

This was clear to me several days ago when I was talking to Kan about attending the workshop and he said, "Ah, but I can learn what I need to learn by reading things online." I didn't chew him out, but tried to explain that the value of the workshop was not just technical knowledge but hearing from the people who worked at other radio stations and being part of a network.

So I tried to work this from three angles: talking to my colleagues at the radio about the workshop, talking to the people who were organizing it to make sure that they had the correct contact information for us, and also talking to the leadership of Ixmukané (or at least getting some messages to them). Since the radio does not operate independently but is under the aegis of the organization Ixmukané everything we do has to be approved by the leadership.

Up until the last minute I didn't know who was going to be attending the workshop on behalf of the radio. As the workshop was postponed, and I was out of the country for a few days the week before the workshop, I wasn't able to stay on top of it. When I came back no one (or I should say no one at the radio) knew who was attending, and neither Kan nor Jeanet were planning to go (they are the only two other people at the radio station full time. Jeanet has children and takes classes on Saturdays; Kan was involved in the dance of the bulls (baile de los toritos), a traditional dance that is performed during the Día de Todos los Santos celebrations, and he had to work on his costume and get ready. But I don't think it was just their lack of interest; the organization's leadership decided to send two other people, who were not part of the radio station. All I had found out before the workshop was that 'two compañeros from Chichi" were going to attend. No one told me who these people were and why they were selected to attend. That didn't seem to make much sense to me but there was nothing I could do about it other than write to the leadership of the organization and reiterate that the workshop was designed to strengthen the work of the radio station, and that costs were only being covered for one person.

Friday afternoon I set off for Xela; I had decided to go the day before so I could avoid having to get up and hit the road at 6 a.m. to get there by 8, and also so I could visit with my friends in Xela. I got a few messages from the secretary of the association asking me for instructions on how to get to the location: apparently that was not part of the invitation, as most people attending had been there before (or people form their radio stations had attended) and so there was not the need. I explained briefly which bus they would need to take from the terminal in Xela and where to get off, and told Tomasita to make sure that they had my phone number to call me.

I arrived at around 9; breakfast was to be at 8 but since I was staying with friends I ate breakfast at their house and just arrived for the workshop. It was lovely to see people again; not all the attendees were people I had met, but several had been either at the last training session or at the national encounter in Guatemala in August or both. I have stayed in touch with a few of them more regularly via phone, email or Facebook, and so I truly view them as friends and colleagues. So it was with great pleasure that I saw Julian from Estero Maya in Momostenango, whom I have visited twice, and Francisco from Snuq Jolom in Santa Eulalia, and Brenda from one of the radio stations around Lake Atitlán, Angelica from Radio Ixchel in Sumpango, and of course the organizers, Tino, Anselmo and Cesar (all of whom are part of the Cultural Survival project).

After we had started the first part of the workshop, my phone rang and it was the two people who had been sent by Ixmukané who were at the pedestrian overpass on the highway. I had known they would call; I realized on my way to the radio station that I had told them to get off at the wrong overpass (there are two in San Mateo, and for some reason I was thinking from the other direction; the last time I had told someone to meet me there, it was my friend Patrick who was coming from the opposite direction, and so I had inadvertently told the folks from Chichi to get off at the first overpass). So I pulled my car out and went and fetched them and had a chance to talk to them a little, so it wouldn't seem as though we didn't know each other at all.

The workshop was fun; a lot of interactive stuff. Some little games that pushed us to think quickly and also identify ourselves. There was a lot of joking and laughter, and now "gringa con sabor"(gringa with flavor) is my official nickname in the community radio movement: my friend Humberto did the opening presentation of the workshop and in the initial round of introductions, after I had presented myself, he added "And she is also known as the gringa con sabor". So the name stuck. And then throughout the weekend, the guys especially kept on asking me "And what flavor is that?", and we would all laugh. My standard responses were, "I don't know, you'll have to ask," (and then if someone pressed, "Who should we ask?" I replied "Boca cerrada no entran moscas" -- flies don't enter a closed mouth), or "Chile picante!" as I also have a reputation for eating a lot of chile.

 There was a theater performance by a group of young people from the area around Lake Atitlán, about HIV/AIDS and the use of condoms, which used a lot of humor but also very explicit instructions on how to use a condom. And then an interesting discussion  about a lot of related issues: questions about other STDs, other methods of contraception, and so forth. Then we set to work to write radio spots: there were about 8 or 10 themes, ranging from family planning to HIV/AIDS, and we were encouraged to use a lot of humor and be creative. 

Activist anthropology: Declaration of the Community Radio Movement


On Sunday (October 30) in the workshop for community radios, I spent the first part of the morning working on a denunciation of a law, initiative 4404, that is being proposed in the Guatemala Congress, that will extend the media monopoly for 25 years. Basically this law guarantees to the people and companies that already hold licenses for radio frequencies, another 25 years of those frequencies, without giving any legal status to community radios. Community radios are in a precarious position as they have no legal standing. They are not illegal technically -- a point we make all the time -- but they do not fit into any of the existing categories of telecommunications law in Guatemala. And so they have no protection. The police or Ministerio Publico can show up any time and just shut down the radio -- they did this a week and a half ago in Chichicastenango.  So, fighting to stop the monopolies, and also to guarantee the rights of community radio stations to have a legal status and enjoy legal protection.


Here is the text of the communication we wrote; this was signed by the 20 radio stations that attended the workshop and then was emailed to the president of the Congress, the congress person who proposed initiative 4404, and the presidential candidate Manuel Baldizón, as the congressman who proposed the law is from his political party, LIDER.



Denounce the Initiative 4404, favoring media monopolies in Guatemala

The community radio movement of Guatemala, in the face of national and international public opinion, denounces that on 27 September this year the deputy Roberto Ricardo Villate Villatoro, of the political party LIDER, presented to the Legislative Department of the Congress, the Initiative with registration number 4404, which aims to renew Radio Frequency Broadcasting law of the Telecommunications Authority, for another 25 years, renewable for equal periods. Extending the use of radio frequencies is a threat to the effort and struggle being made by the community radio movement, which for 14 years has proposed that the right of indigenous peoples and other traditionally excluded sectors, to have their own means of communication, be recognized within the legal framework of the country. This proposed bill contradicts the provisions of Subsection H of the Agreement on Identity and Rights of Indigenous Peoples (of the Peace Accords), Article 35 of the Political Constitution of the Republic and international agreements. Freedom of expression is a human right guarantted in Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of the United Nations and in Article 13 of the Convention of the Organization of American States. Furthermore, Article 16 of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples specifies the right of indigenous peoples have their own media.

We ask those honest members of Congress elected by popular vote to oppose the adoption of the initiative 4404 presented by Deputy Villate Villatoro, which only serves the interests of the monopoly of the media in Guatemala, and not the interests of the excluded majority. Furthermore, we demand that the Congress facilitate approval of  Initiative 4087 on Community Media, which already has received a favorable opinion from the Commission on Indigenous Peoples of the Congress.

We ask for the solidarity of the social movements and other civil society institutions in denouncing these violations, and to support, defend and strengthen the work of community radio.

For indigenous peoples' right to the means of communication
The Community Radio Movement of Guatemala
Just as we finished writing and translating and printing out a copy, at the training center in San Mateo, a car stopped by, with the newly elected congressperson from LIDER, representing Quetzaltenango, and we gave him a copy personally, and explained what it was about.  

Friday, October 28, 2011

Por que fui a Wall Street

Para el mes pasado mi atención se ha dividido entre Guatemala y el movimiento ocupa en los EE.UU., sobre todo en mi ciudad natal de Nueva York. Por supuesto, sabemos que esta ola de protestas y acciones públicas no se inició en Nueva York. No hubo protestas militantes en Europa, en Egipto, en América Latina, y el pueblo de los EE.UU. se han unido a la ola de descontento. Y sin embargo, la importancia de esta ronda particular de las acciones no puede ser minimizado. Que representa, creo, algo nuevo. Exactamente lo que es algo nuevo, es todavía en proceso.

Así pues, he estado viendo esta a una distancia, más intensamente después de las primeras dos semanas. Parecía como si todos los que conocía en Nueva York estaba ocupando - si no se duerme en Zuccotti Park, a continuación, participar en otras formas.Algunos de mis amigos han visitado casi todos los días desde que empezó. Algunos están participando en los múltiples grupos de trabajo que se han establecido, o hacer un punto de asistir a las Asambleas Generales cada noche, que es donde los grupos de trabajo en el informe, cualquier persona que quiera puede plantear una inquietud, y las decisiones estratégicas se toman por consenso de quien está participando. Otros han venido sólo para las marchas más grandes y las acciones de apoyo.


Amigos en otros lugares - Filadelfia, Colorado - también se han arrojado a este. Y por lo que había empezado la comprobación de varias veces al día, en su mayoría a través de Facebook y el correo electrónico (como muchos de mis amigos están involucrados y que publican con bastante regularidad) y buscando en la web Ocupar Wall Street, y también ver lo que la cobertura de los medios ha sido. Yo estaba en Guatemala durante la primavera árabe llamada. Vi la plaza Tahrir se desarrollan a través de CNN, Al Jazeera y diversas fuentes basadas en la Web, sino que comenzó poco después de que llegué aquí en enero. He visto a los otros movimientos de protesta en los últimos meses. Pero éste era en mi ciudad natal - Yo no nací en Nueva York, pero he vivido allí durante casi 35 años, ya que todos los otros lugares donde he vivido juntos. Y así empecé a sentir como si yo debería tratar de llegar allí.


Hace aproximadamente un mes, había hecho planes (aunque, afortunadamente, que no incluyen la compra de billetes de avión) para ir a Nueva Orleans para el fin de semana del 22 de octubre y 23 para el 50 cumpleaños de un amigo a quien no hemos visto desde 2009. Se trataba de una extravagancia, pero me dijo que no iba a cumplir 50 años de nuevo, y valdría la pena. Él y su esposa se había movido desde que estaba allí por último, a un nuevo apartamento, y aunque sólo hemos encontrado cara a cara un puñado de veces (que eran refugiados del Katrina que se hizo amigo de mi hija en 2005), yo las considero (y sobre todo lo ) muy queridos amigos, y parecía tan feliz cuando me sugirió que yo podría llegar, que me decidí al diablo con todo, yo iba a ir. Después de todo, me dije, es sólo dinero.


Desafortunadamente, mi amigo tuvo que cancelar su celebración, y gracias a Dios me hizo saber antes de que yo había comprado un billete de avión. Por lo tanto, tomé la decisión de fracción de segundo. Como yo tenía ya mentalmente a un lado el dinero para el billete de avión a Nueva Orleans, yo lo uso para ir a Nueva York. He consultado con algunos amigos que han estado activos en Ocupar Wall Street (OWS) para ver si ellos pensaban que todavía podría estar pasando a mi regreso en enero. El clima, por supuesto, sería mucho más frío. Todos dijeron que sí, pero yo todavía pensaba que era importante ir ahora, mientras que el tiempo era un poco más cálido, y antes de que pudiera haber ninguna represalia policial a gran escala.


Me sentí como si yo necesitaba para no ir, porque mi presencia habría ninguna diferencia enorme, y no porque pensé que iba a cambiar mi vida. Pero parecía que esto era una cosa única e importante - una ruptura histórica, uno de mis amigos lo describen, una abertura en la superficie de la política como la hemos conocido. Me pareció importante estar ahí, ya que una de las cosas que parecían tan importante fue la recuperación de los bienes comunes, como Joel Kovel lo expreso cuando me encontré con él en la noche del miércoles cuando estaba a punto de irme de OWS y volver a Brooklyn y luego a Guatemala. Y se sentía como si fuera algo que tenía que ser experimentado, no simplemente a través de los vídeos de Youtube y las actualizaciones de Facebook. No es como si hubiera una escasez de cosas políticamente significativo que estoy haciendo aquí en Guatemala, o la falta de causas y acciones con las que podía afiliarse a mí mismo. Pero esto ocurría en mi país, el vientre de la bestia, y aunque parecía que de alguna manera alejada de las preocupaciones de la gente de aquí, se sentía como lo que hay que hacer.


Así que rápidamente hice planes - que sólo podía ir por un corto tiempo, ya que no quería tomar mucho tiempo lejos de mi investigación y mi diversos compromisos aquí. En noviembre ya tenía dos conferencias fuera del país, y yo tenía previsto visitar Todos Santos Cuchumatán para el Día de Todos los Santos (Noviembre 1, pero la fiesta continuará durante varios días antes y después), por lo que quería no volver a viajes de regreso. Hubo una sesión de entrenamiento para la gente de las radios comunitarias el fin de semana del 22 de octubre y el 23 (me enteré después de la fiesta de cumpleaños había sido cancelada) por lo que fue otro factor.


He consultado con mi hija, como yo quería verla, y ella dijo que el lunes fue su mejor día. Así que registre vuelos y enconte una tarifa barata saliendo el domingo a las 6 pm,  de llegar a Nueva York el lunes a las 7 am con un vuelo de vuelta partiendo en la mañana del miércoles. Así invente  este plan completamente loco: yo asistir al taller en Xela, el sábado y luego en algún momento domingo conduciría directamente desde Xela hasta el aeropuerto. Eso significaría que sólo 48 horas en Nueva York, una extravagancia, sin duda, pero que me permita cumplir con mis obligaciones aquí y también tener un sabor breve OWS.Y entonces se me ocurrió que yo podría añadir mi granito de arena al hablar de Guatemala. Sabía que había un programa completo de charlas y otras actividades educativas, y algunos de mis amigos estaban en el grupo de educación de trabajo, así que lo que se les propuse.


Sin embargo, debido al mal tiempo, el taller se pospuso hasta el 29 de octubre y 30.¡Maldita sea! Me podría haber pasado más tiempo en Nueva York, mientras yo estaba haciendo el viaje. Miré para vuelos alternativos, pero cambia la reserva habría costado demasiado, así que lo dejé como estaba previsto.